Harvard v. the Trump Administration: Status of the Disputes

As of November 16, 2026

This is a summary of the legal actions and threatened legal actions that have arisen between Harvard and the Trump Administration since April 2025, when the Trump Administration began its campaign against Harvard. Harvard has won every court ruling so far, but none of the disputes is finally over. Two appeals argued in October 2026 await decision, and several other fronts remain investigations or threats. All the court proceedings referenced below have occurred in the U.S. District Court for the District of Massachusetts or the U.S. Court of Appeals for the First Circuit, the appellate court that hears appeals from the Massachusetts district court.

Background

  • In April 2025, a federal executive branch task force demanded changes to Harvard’s governance, hiring, admissions and discipline, citing campus antisemitism. Harvard refused.

  • The administration froze about $2.2 billion in research grants, then opened fronts on international students, patents, visas, tax status and admissions data.

  • Harvard is the only major university to fight in court rather than settle, as Columbia, Brown and others did.

1. Research Funding Case (Dispute began April 2025)

Status: Harvard won summary judgment in the trial court; the government’s First Circuit appeal was argued October 5, 2026, and a decision is pending.

  • On September 3, 2025, Judge Allison Burroughs restored $2.2 billion in grants and $60 million in contracts. She found First Amendment retaliation and a failure to follow Title VI procedures, calling the DOJ antisemitism rationale a “smokescreen.”

  • On appeal, DOJ argues this is a contract dispute that belongs in the Court of Federal Claims. Harvard says it seeks a forward-looking injunction only a district court can grant.

  • The panel (Judges Lynch, Gelpí and Dunlap) appeared skeptical of the government; Judge Lynch noted there were no findings on antisemitism before the government cuts.

2. International Students (SEVP Certification and Proclamation) (Dispute began May 2025)

Status: Harvard can still enroll international students under court orders; the appeal was argued October 6, 2026, and a decision is pending.

  • In May 2025, DHS revoked Harvard’s certification to enroll F and J visa students. In June 2025, the President barred entry of foreign students coming to Harvard. Judge Burroughs enjoined both.

  • The proclamation expired in December 2025, and the First Circuit panel questioned whether the appeal is moot. DOJ told the court Trump “would likely reissue” it if the injunction is lifted.

3. Title VI Antisemitism Lawsuit (Dispute began March 2026)

Status: Dismissed August 13, 2026; DOJ’s appeal to the First Circuit is in its early stages.

  • DOJ sued March 20, 2026, alleging “deliberate indifference” to antisemitism after October 7, 2023, and seeking to cut off funding and recover nearly $1 billion in grants.

  • Judge Richard Stearns found the incidents “too isolated and episodic” to show continuing noncompliance, stressing that Title VI aims at future compliance, not punishment for past conduct.

  • DOJ noticed its appeal August 28, 2026. Watch for its opening brief and the briefing schedule.

4. Admissions Records Lawsuit (Dispute began February 2026)

Status: Dismissed on procedural grounds November 2, 20 26; the government may refile.

  • DOJ sued in February 2026 to compel applicant-level admissions data, to test compliance with the Supreme Court’s 2023 affirmative action ruling. Harvard produced over 2,000 pages but withheld individual files.

  • Judge Myong Joun held that DOJ had not sought voluntary compliance or given required notice, and that the Education Department skipped its own procedures. He left the merits and Harvard’s retaliation claim open.

  • Watch for a refiled suit, an appeal or new demands.

5. Patent “March-In” Threat (Bayh-Dole Act) (Dispute began August 2025)

Status: A threat only; no formal proceeding has been reported.

  • On August 8, 2025, Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick announced a review of Harvard’s compliance on federally funded patents and threatened to license them to others or take title.

  • The government has never exercised march-in rights since the 1980 law was enacted; any attempt would be unprecedented, disputed by tech companies, and almost certainly litigated.

6. J-1 Exchange Visitor Investigations and Visa Limits (Dispute began July 2025)

Status: Two investigations are open and Harvard has been subpoenaed; no findings yet. A proposed rule capping visas has been enjoined.

  • In July 2025, Secretary of State Rubio opened a review of Harvard’s eligibility to sponsor J-1 exchange visitors, mostly researchers and scholars.

  • On October 8, 2026, Vice President Vance announced a Labor Department inspector general probe of Harvard and eight other universities for alleged J-1 abuse and foreign influence. Harvard is reviewing its subpoena.

  • A DHS rule capping F and J visas at four years was blocked by Judge Dennis Saylor on September 14, 2026, in a suit by higher education groups.

7. Tax-Exempt Status (Dispute began April 2025)

Status: Harvard remains tax-exempt; no formal IRS action has been reported.

  • Trump vowed in April 2025 to revoke the exemption, but only the IRS can do so, and federal law bars the President from directing IRS action against a particular taxpayer.

  • On September 3, 2026, Treasury and the IRS proposed rules to revoke the exemption of schools found to discriminate by race. If finalized, they take effect in summer 2027 and could reach Harvard depending on the admissions fight.

  • Separately, the tax on Harvard’s endowment income rose from 1.4% to 8% under 2025 legislation.

8. Other Fronts

  • EEOC: On September 30, 2026, the EEOC sued to enforce a subpoena for faculty hiring records in a probe of alleged bias against white, male, Asian and straight applicants. Harvard calls it retaliatory.  

  • Pentagon: In August 2026, the Defense Department ordered Harvard and 29 other universities to audit foreign partnerships or risk research funding.

Next
Next

How students led a push to improve Harvard’s intellectual climate